Showing posts with label nurse staffing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nurse staffing. Show all posts

Friday, April 24, 2015

Study Finds Patients Admitted to Hospitals on Weekends are at Greater Risk for “Never Events”

Falls and infections are more common among patients admitted to hospitals on weekends, according to a new study conducted by researchers at the University of Southern California and published in the British Medical Journal. The research team analyzed data from more than 350 million hospital admissions from 2002 to 2010. Even though the vast majority (81 percent) of the admissions were on weekdays, there were more complications in patients admitted on weekends (5.7 percent of complications compared with 3.7 percent for patients admitted on week days). The most common kinds of hospital-acquired infections among patients admitted on weekends were pressure ulcers and catheter-associated urinary tract infections.

The research team could not determine whether the higher proportion of complications were due to lower staffing rates on weekends or patients with more urgent treatment needs being admitted during those times.

These findings are consistent with a body of research showing that patients admitted during off-peak hours (like evenings and weekends) experienced more health problems, and were less likely to survive in-hospital cardiac arrest, and that newborns born on weekends were more likely to die than babies born during the week.

An INQRI-funded study led by Patti Hamilton and Gretchen Gemeinhardt found that nurses’ “off-peak” work environments play a significant role in the increased patient mortality during these time periods.  In particular, the researchers found that nurses who participate in hospital plans that allow them to work only weekend shifts for full pay and benefits are less familiar with their institutions’ initiatives and priorities that govern policies, procedures, principles and regulations for providing care, because those initiatives and priorities are stressed more during peak periods.

Friday, January 16, 2015

Washington Post Tackles Nurse Staffing Minimums, Quotes INQRI Experts

A recent Washington Post article analyzing the impact of nurse staffing minimums provides insight from two INQRI advisors.

 “There’s plenty of evidence that there’s a shortage of nursing care, and it’s not solved by anything to do with the hospital supply,”  Linda Aiken, INQRI research manager and National Advisory Committee member, tells the Washington Post. “All the shortage of care at the bedside has to do with how much hospitals want to pay nurses, and whether they want to use their resources on something else.”

Aiken’s recent research, published in the Lancet in February 2014, found that patients are more likely to die after common surgical procedures when they are cared for in hospitals with heavier nurse workloads and fewer nurses with bachelor's degrees. The study found that every extra patient increased the chance of surgical patients dying within 30 days of admission by 7 percent.

A California law requiring mandatory minimum nurse staffing has shown benefit for nurses, with studies showing that patient loads and rates of occupational injury decreased in the state, while job satisfaction among nurses increased. The Post reports, however, that there is conflicting evidence as to whether legislating mandatory minimum staffing improves patient outcomes. Lori Melichar, a labor economist for RWJF and program officer for INQRI, tells the Post that the question is complicated. “And when you layer on ‘Is this policy going to be effective,’ as a researcher and an economist, I can’t make that determination,” she says.

An INQRI-funded study on the impact of nursing staffing on hospital performance revealed that increasing the number of registered nurse (RN) hours per patient day increased the quality of patient care. The study looked in particular at patients who were being treated for acute myocardial infarction, pneumonia or heart failure.) For all three conditions, increasing the number of RN hours increased the quality of care. This did not hold true for increasing the number of licensed practical nurse or nursing assistant hours.

The study's authors—Gestur Davidson, Ira Moscovice, and Kathy Belk—posited that RNs are involved in and directly affect procedures, practices and processes that directly influence patient outcomes. This was the first study into how nurse staffing affects hospital performance on quality metrics used in the Premier Hospital Quality Demonstration project. It is reviewed in a 2013 research brief on the RWJF website.

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Patient Satisfaction, Outcomes Could Improve with Use of Nursing Quality Analytics Data

Having access to a quality analytics database that measures clinical data specific to the role of nurses as well as data about the nursing environment, could help improve patient satisfaction and outcomes nationwide, according to Christina Dempsey, chief nursing officer at Press Ganey.

Press Ganey, an organization that works to help hospitals and other medical facilities improve patient experiences, recently acquired the National Database of Nursing Quality Indicators (NDNQI) from the American Nursing Association (ANA). NDNQI includes clinical quality measures and corresponding information on nurse engagement and the nursing environment. Press Ganey is distilling the data into four areas that affect the patient experience. They believe this approach will ultimately help their clients decide where to invest in improvements.

“Nurse-sensitive indicators reflect the structure, the process and the outcomes of nursing care,” Dempsey told HealthITAnalytics. “The structure of nursing care is indicated by the supply of the nursing staff, the skill level of the nursing staff, and the education of the nursing staff.  Process indicators measure things like assessments, intervention, and job satisfaction.  And then outcomes are those things that improve if there’s a greater quantity or quality of nursing care, such as pressure ulcers and falls.”

“… Being able to bring some of that data together will allow managers, clinicians, and nurses at the bedside better understand what they need to do for which population of patients to get the highest and best return,” Dempsey said.

Wednesday, July 9, 2014

Finding Solutions for Stressed Out, Exhausted Nurses, and Potentially Depressed RNs

A new survey of more than 3,300 registered nurses (RNs) shows that a majority were extremely stressed out due to lack of sleep, long hours, and numerous other workplace issues.

These high levels of stress and fatigue could lead to medical errors, and negative patient outcomes, as well as an increase in nurse burnout, further aggravating the current nursing shortage, according to the study by the Vickie Milazzo Institute, a legal nurse consulting training institute.

Among the findings, 64 percent of respondents indicated that they rarely get seven to eight hours of sleep and 33 percent said they hardly ever get that amount. Twelve-hour shifts and on-call shifts after regular shifts and overnight shifts contribute to the fatigue problem, according to the study. Fatigue and irregular sleep patterns can also lead to health problems for nurses, including increased risk of depression and anxiety disorders.

An INQRI-funded study, published in the May/June 2012 issue of the journal Clinical Nurse Specialist, looked at how depression and musculoskeletal pain among nurses impacts workplace productivity and quality of patient care. Researchers found that nurses experience depressive symptoms at a rate twice as high—18 percent—as the general public. The team found that pain and depression were significantly associated with presenteeism, which was significantly associated with patient falls, medication errors, and the perceived quality of care. Additionally, depressed workers often exhibit low mood, have difficulty concentrating, and are accident-prone.

The researchers analyzed surveys from 1,171 hospital nurses in North Carolina and found that the productivity loss due to pain and/or depression was $14,339 per nurse and $876.9 million for the state of North Carolina. If these numbers were extrapolated to the nation, the productivity loss would be $22.7 billion.

Addressing the Problems

According to the Milazzo study, other factors contributing to high levels of stress for RNs are an unhealthy work/life balance, lack of authority, recognition, and fair pay in the workplace, and lack of effective management. To address these issues, the study recommends that hospitals:
  • Make work hours for RNs realistic and sane;
  • Provide access to nutritious food;
  • Allow experienced RNs to have the authority to do their jobs and provide RNs with management opportunities; and
  • Improve management style to recognize RN’s unique contributions and provide fair pay, adequate paid time off, and a positive work environment.
As the INQRI study points out, it is also imperative to devote more attention to depression screening and early treatment for nurses. Advanced practice nurses can educate staff RNs about the high prevalence of depression in nurses, who, like the general population, may be reluctant to get screening and treatment, due to the social stigma attached to mental illness. The study identified Web-based screening as a confidential and cost-effective means of reaching the nursing population.

Other strategies for assisting nurses with depression include increasing staff nurses and managers’ awareness of and sensitivity to depression, advocating policies that support good mental health and treatment for those with problems, and promoting supportive work environments, according to the study.

The Effects of Nurse Presenteeism on Quality of Care and Patient Safety was led by INQRI grantees Susan Letvak and Christopher J. Ruhm.

The Vickie Milazzo Institute survey results are available here.

Friday, June 13, 2014

Nurse Investigator Group Develops Plan to Increase Nurse Time in Patients’ Rooms

After an internal investigation showed that nurses spent only two-and-a-half to three hours on patient care during a 12-hour shift, and that much of their time was spent on activities that could be done by other staffers, Novant Health brought together a group of nurses to further investigate the issue and find a solution, Becker’s Hospital Review reports. 

The nurse investigator group identified four major activities that accounted for most of nurses’ time away from patients’ rooms: including finding supplies; obtaining medications; care planning; and preparing paperwork required for admitting patients. Novant, based in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, then set a goal of having nurses spend 70 percent of their time in a patient's room, reducing the amount of time spent on these tasks.

"Over the course of the last three years following that, we've worked on care team models that included having the nurse define what the top of their license performance would look like," Sallye Liner, Novant's chief clinical officer, tells Becker’s. "It was clear that we would need a team of people wrapped around nurses to make sure all of the needs of the patient were met."

Novant hired certified nursing assistants to perform many of the activities that had been taking nurses away from patients’ rooms. The system also implemented electronic medical records and placed monitors in patients' rooms to save time in documentation. Other changes included pharmacy techs delivering medications to patient rooms instead of nurses having to hunt them down for each patient.

Novant has implemented changes in all of its 15 hospitals and found that nurses now spend 72 percent of their time in patient rooms. Novant saw reductions in falls and infections and increases in patient satisfaction. Turnover rates among nurses have also declined, thanks to the changes, Liner tells Becker’s.

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

When It Comes to Cost and Quality of Hospital Care, Nurse Tenure and Teamwork Count

This post originally appeared on the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Human Capital Blog.

The largest study to examine the relationship between nurse staffing and patient care reveals that patients get the best care when they are treated in hospital units staffed by teams of nurses who have extensive experience in their current jobs. The study, conducted by an interdisciplinary team including Patricia Stone, PhD, RN, FAAN, Centennial Professor of Health Policy at the Columbia University School of Nursing and Ciaran Phibbs, PhD, research economist at the Health Economics Resource Center at the Palo Alto Veterans Administration Health Care System, was funded by the Interdisciplinary Nursing Quality Research Initiative (INQRI).

The research team reviewed more than 900,000 patient admissions over four years (from 2003 through 2006) at hospitals in the Veterans Administration Health Care System. They analyzed nurses’ payroll records and patients’ medical records to see how nurse staffing affected patients’ length of stay. Longer hospital stays tend to be associated with delays and errors in care delivery, so shorter stays indicate better care. Shorter stays also reduce the cost of care.

Researchers found that a one-year increase in the average tenure of registered nurses (RNs) on a hospital unit was associated with a 1.3 percent decrease in the average length of stay.
The study also found that patients’ length of stay was longer when a member of a team of experienced RNs was missing or a new member was added to the team. Stone, one of the principal investigators, notes that “when the same team of nurses works together over the years, the nurses develop a rhythm and routine that lead to more efficient care.”

The researchers note that their findings suggest that hospital executives should consider policies that will help them retain experienced nurses and that encourage nurses to remain on their current units.

The paper, “Human Capital and Productivity in a Team Environment for the Healthcare Sector” was published in the April 2014 issue of American Economics Journal: Applied Economics.

The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation created INQRI to generate, disseminate, and translate research to understand how nurses contribute to and can improve patient care quality.

Friday, April 18, 2014

Nurses' Experience and Teamwork Contribute to Better Patient Care

A new study partially funded through the INQRI program reveals that nurse tenure and good team work improve the quality of hospital care and reduce costs. The research team, led by INQRI grantee Patricia Stone, found that patients received the best care when treated by nurses who have extensive experience in their current job. The study is in the current issue of the American Economics Journal: Applied Economics.

Stone and her team reviewed more than 900,000 patient admissions over four years at Veterans Administration Healthcare System hospitals. It is the largest study of its kind to link nurse staffing to patient outcomes, according to a statement by Columbia University Medical Center. Stone, centennial professor of health policy at Columbia Nursing, and her co-authors analyzed payroll records for individual nurses and medical records for individual patients to examine how changes in nurse staffing impacted length of stay.

"Reducing length of stay is the holy grail of hospital management because it means patients are getting higher quality, more cost-effective care," Stone said in the statement. "When the same team of nurses works together over the years, the nurses develop a rhythm and routines that lead to more efficient care. Hospitals need to keep this in mind when making staffing decisions–disrupting the balance of a team can make quality go down and costs go up."

Stone’s earlier INQRI-funded project: “The Impacts of Nurse Staffing, Skill Mix, and Experience on Quality and Costs in Long-Term Care” examined whether there is a causal relationship between nursing input and patient outcomes in long-term care facilities.

Thursday, April 10, 2014

Increasing Both Nurse and Doctor Staffing Levels Can Reduce Patient Mortality in ICUs – but Nurses Are Key

A new study in the International Journal of Nursing Studies finds that higher staffing levels for doctors and nurses in intensive care units (ICUs) are associated with higher survival rates for patients at high risk for death. The report, titled “Nurse staffing, medical staffing and mortality in Intensive Care: an observational study,” examines whether the number of nurses, doctors, and support staff affected the survival chances of critically ill patients in both the ICU and the hospital, HealthCanal reports.

Researchers reviewed information on nearly 40,000 patients from 65 ICUs in the United Kingdom. Among the findings, higher numbers of nurses per bed were associated with higher survival rates, and the number of nurses had the greatest impact on patients at a high risk of death when compared to other medical staffing levels.

An INQRI-funded study on the impact of nursing staffing on hospital performance revealed that increasing the number of registered nurse (RN) hours per patient day increased the quality of patient care. The study looked in particular at patients who were being treated for acute myocardial infarction, pneumonia or heart failure.) For all three conditions, increasing the number of RN hours increased the quality of care. This did not hold true for increasing the number of licensed practical nurse or nursing assistant hours.

The study's authors—Gestur Davidson, Ira Moscovice, and Kathy Belk—posited that RNs are involved in and directly affect procedures, practices and processes that directly influence patient outcomes. This was the first study into how nurse staffing affects hospital performance on quality metrics used in the Premier Hospital Quality Demonstration project. It is reviewed in a research brief on the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation website.

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

RWJF Hosts Online Readmissions Discussion

The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) Human Capital Network is presenting an online chat on reducing hospital readmissions Monday, March 31, 2014, from 3:15 p.m.-4:00 p.m., ET.

Issues surrounding improving care transitions in order to prevent avoidable hospital readmissions will be discussed. Recent research that highlights how nurse staffing rates can improve patient outcomes will be featured. Topics will include: the variables that cause readmissions; national trends in readmission rates; and interventions for preventing unnecessary readmissions.

Presenters include RWJF Senior Program Officer Susan Mende and Matthew McHugh, associate professor of Nursing at the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing and an RWJF Nurse Faculty Scholar.

McHugh’s research focuses on the effects of policy and organizational factors on nursing practice and health outcomes.

Mende is engaged in an RWJF national program effort to help consumers take an active role in improving the quality of health care in their communities.

Questions can be asked live during the event or in advance by emailing: hcfeedback@rwjf.org.

Registration for the chat is available here.

For more information contact Sue Stine, RWJF Human Capital Network Community Manager, (240) 221-4316; hcfeedback@rwjf.org.

Thursday, February 20, 2014

Staff Turnover Linked to Poor Patient Outcomes in LTCs

Two recent studies suggest that preventing staff turnover should be given greater emphasis in long-term care facilities (LTCs), Advanced Healthcare Network for Nurses reports. The studies examined the relationship between turnover of nursing staff and quality of care for nursing homes residents and found negative outcomes for patients in facilities with high turnover.

Published in December 2013, both studies were based on data from the 2004 National Nursing Home Survey. The first, "Are Nursing Home Survey Deficiencies Higher in Facilities with Greater Staff Turnover," found that turnover for both licensed nurses and certified nursing assistants (CNAs) were associated with problems in quality of care, qualify of life, and resident behavior deficiencies. The second study, "Turnover Staffing, Skill Mix, and Resident Outcomes in a National Sample of U.S. Nursing Homes," found a relationship between high turnover among CNAs and adverse patient outcomes such as pressure ulcers, urinary tract infections, and pain.

An INQRI study led by Robin Newhouse and Laura Morlock, published in the May 2013 issue of Medical Care, underscores the importance of nurse staffing in providing quality care. The researchers tested in 23 rural hospitals a quality collaborative intervention to improve care for heart failure patients. At the end of the study, the researchers found no quantitative difference between the intervention and control groups on implementation of the key measures. They did find that hospitals with lower turnover in nurse staffing implemented more of the measures. The researchers assert that the study speaks to the central role of nurses in quality improvement.

INQRI also looked at patient outcomes in LTCs in The Res-Care-AL Intervention Study.  Researchers, led by Barbara Resnick and Sheryl Zimmerman, conducted a randomized controlled trial to test Function Focused Care – Assisted Living, an intervention designed to maintain and improve function, physical activity, muscle strength, psychosocial outcomes, and decrease adverse events (pain, falls, and hospitalizations) among assisted living residents.

Monday, January 13, 2014

Staffing Issues a Factor in Higher Weekend Hospitalization Mortality Rates

Patients hospitalized on weekends are at a 15 percent higher risk of dying due to issues related to nurse and physician staffing and training, according to a new report. Researchers concluded that “low staffing levels of nurses and physicians significantly impact mortality.” Mortality rates were also higher among patients admitted to the hospital on weekends in hospitals with less experienced staff, such as resident trainees.

The study, which is currently available in provisional form, was conducted by researchers from Tufts Medical Center in Boston who examined data on more than 48 million patients admitted to hospitals for non-elective reasons from January 1, 2003-December 31, 2008.

Researchers found that the overall odds of mortality were higher for patients in hospitals with fewer nurses and staff physicians. Hospitals with more nurses or physicians per hospital bed had a 10 percent lower rate of mortality after a weekend admission. Mortality in hospitals with the highest number of resident trainees was 17 percent higher following a weekend admission, compared with hospitals with no resident trainees.

An INQRI study, “The Effect of Off-peak Hospital Environments on Nurses' Work: an Institutional Ethnography” also revealed the negative impact of weekend and evening admissions on mortality rates. The INQRI study showed that nurses’ “off-peak” work environments play a significant role in the increased patient mortality.

In off-peak environments, nurses have less access to support, work with less supervision, and have strained communication with on-call health care providers, the study found. Researchers identified ways in which nurse administrators can mitigate the possible reasons for these disparities:
  • Being conscious of the fact that the majority of hours nurses work are “off-peak” and ensuring that institutions’ efforts and programs include peak and “off-peak” times;
  • Knowing that implementing a solution for a problem that occurs during peak hours may unintentionally create a problem for those nurses who work “off-peak” and involving nurses from every shift in planning and evaluating work processes;
  • Collecting performance data in a way that allows for comparing that data across days of the week and times (both peak and “off-peak”), rather than aggregating data over 24 hours or over an entire week; and
  • Proactively addressing nurse-physician relations in the hospital.
The INQRI grantees were Patti Hamilton and Gretchen Gemeinhardt.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Increased RN Staffing Hours Are Correlated with Higher Quality Patient Care

An INQRI-funded study on the impact of nursing staffing on hospital performance revealed that increasing the number of registered nurse (RN) hours per patient day increased the quality of patient care. The study looked in particular at patients who were being treated for acute myocardial infarction, pneumonia or heart failure.)  For all three conditions, increasing the number of RN hours increased the quality of care. This did not hold true for increasing the number of licensed practical nurse (LPN) or nursing assistant (NA) hours.

The study's authors -- Gestur Davidson, Ira Moscovice and Kathy Belk -- posited that RNs are involved in and directly affect procedures, practices and processes that directly influence patient outcomes. This was the first study into how nurse staffing affects hospital performance on quality metrics used in the Premier Hospital Quality Demonstration project. It is reviewed in a new research brief on the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation website.


Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Do Public Reporting Laws Affect Nurse Staffing, Patient Safety?

A new $214,000 grant from RWJF’s Future of Nursing National Research Agenda will fund a study to examine whether public reporting laws are effective in encouraging hospitals to improve nurse staffing levels and improving patient outcomes. The project is coordinated by INQRI and the team is led by Matthew D. McHugh, associate professor at the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing, Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research. McHugh is also an RWJF Nurse Faculty Scholar.

The researchers will examine the impact of nurse staffing public reporting laws on staffing levels and patient outcomes in four states: Illinois, New Jersey, Rhode Island, and Vermont. They will look at the scope of nurse staffing public reporting laws, the process and context that supported their passage and implementation, the effects of the laws on registered nurse staffing levels, and the effects of the laws on patient mortality, readmissions, and failure-to-rescue.

“The studies funded through the Interdisciplinary Nursing Quality Research Initiative are establishing the links between nursing care and patient outcomes, and this new round of research takes that work one step further,” said INQRI Co-director Mary Naylor. “The National Research Agenda supports studies that will provide the evidence base for policies that will advance nursing, improve health care, and increase access to care.”

A news release on the new grant is here.

Friday, October 18, 2013

Nursing Economic$ Journal Feature: Leading Nurse Researcher Cites Importance of Transparency in Nurse Staffing Ratios

The September-October 2013 issue of Nursing Economic$ journal features the first in an insightful interview series with Linda H. Aiken PhD, FAAN, FRCN, RN, a member of the INQRI National Advisory Committee and a Research Manager supporting the Future of Nursing: Campaign for Action.

“The Impact of Research on Staffing: an Interview with Linda Aiken” covers numerous areas of nurse staffing, including the viability of public reporting as an alternative to legislatively-mandated nurse staffing ratios.

“If we had more transparent information on what staffing levels are at hospitals, consumers and nurses could exercise more informed choices in selecting a hospital for care or employment,” Aiken told NursingEconomic$. “Also, easily accessible information on staffing would expose hospitals with particularly poor staffing to increased public and professional scrutiny which would be expected to motivate improvements.”

Aiken also praises the 2013 Safe Nurse Staffing Act, introduced in Congress in April 2013, which proposes public reporting of nurse staffing on the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Hospital Compare website.

Other topics covered in the interview include: variations of nurse staffing ratios across the country; inadequate staffing at minority hospitals; the impact of healthcare reform on nurse staffing; and addressing work environment issues. The second part of Aiken’s interview will be featured in the November/December 2013 issue of Nursing Economic$.

Monday, October 14, 2013

Research Brief: Quality of Nursing Care on Acute Inpatient Units

Does the composition of hospital nurse staffing levels matter when it comes to preventing costly complications and death following those complications? A team at the University of California, led by Mary Blegen, Tom Vaughn (from the University of Iowa) and Colleen Goode (from the University of Colorado), examined the extent to which nurse staffing levels affected the incidence of complications and the failure to rescue from those complications, (i.e. death following complications). Their examination showed that nursing hours per patient day were strongly associated with lower rates of pressure ulcers and hospital acquired infections, and fewer deaths from complications. Further, more RN hours in the mix had additional benefit with still lower rates of failure to rescue and hospital acquired infections. Their work shows that higher levels of nursing hours per patient day and RN skill mix in intensive care units and in general units will lead to better patient outcomes, information that can guide states considering regulation of nurse-patient staffing ratios to address patient safety gaps.

Access the research brief.

This post is part of a series to provide the public with research briefs on INQRI-funded projects across a range of interests.

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Higher Nurse Staffing Levels Decrease Odds of Penalties for Excessive Readmissions

A study published in Health Affairs finds that hospitals with higher nurse-to-patient ratios are less likely to be penalized for excessive readmissions under the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) of the Affordable Care Act. HRRP penalizes hospitals that have excessive 30-day readmissions for Medicare patients admitted for heart attacks, heart failure or pneumonia, it is anticipated to reduce hospital payments by roughly $280 million in fiscal year 2013.

Matthew McHugh, a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Nurse Faculty Scholar lead the research team. He and his colleagues noted that nurses are primarily responsible for a wide range of activities that can reduce readmissions, including care coordination and oversight, discharge planning, and patient education. When nurses have adequate time to complete those activities, readmissions rates are lower.

Read the news release about this study here.

Monday, October 7, 2013

Research Brief: Supplemental Nurse Staffing

A team of researchers at the University of Rochester, led by Ying Xue and Deborah Freund, conducted a study to better understand one hospital's use of supplemental registered nurses (SRNs) and examine its impact on patient and nurse outcomes and cost. Using focus groups, interviews, mail surveys, chart reviews and reviewing hospital administration data, the team found that use of SRNs varied greatly by unit and that typically permanent RNs have similar experience and more education (BSN or higher degree). Although, the use of supplemental nurses occurred more frequently in units that were rated as having poor working environments, the team did not find that their use had any negative impact on patient or nurse outcomes. The findings of this project will further understanding of the impact of SRNs on quality and cost outcomes and help hospital administrators make evidence-based strategic plan for nurse staffing.
Access the research brief.

This post is part of a series to provide the public with research briefs on INQRI-funded projects across a range of interests.

Thursday, September 26, 2013

Employing Substantial Numbers of Foreign Educated Nurses in U.S. Hospitals Raises Risks of Poor Patient Outcomes

New Study Shows More Deaths in U.S. Hospitals That Have Higher Percentages of Nurses Educated Abroad

For over 60 years, U.S. hospitals have employed non-US-educated nurses during nurse shortages to supplement their workforce.  Although recruitment of nurses from abroad is cyclical, many foreign-educated nurses that come to the U.S. in times of shortages end up staying.  Thus their presence in the U.S. nurse workforce is long-lasting.

Little is known about the impact of foreign educated nurses on quality of hospital care in the U.S.  The majority of foreign-educated nurses in the U.S. are from countries with transitional economies, such as the Philippines, where the health care system is substantially different from that of the U.S. Unlike requirements for foreign trained physicians who practice in the U.S., nurses are not required to complete any educational program in the U.S. if they pass the licensure exam, English speaking and comprehension exams, and provide evidence that their education is “equivalent” to that required of U.S. nurses.  However, nurses from countries with transitional economies have RN licensure exam pass rates significantly lower than that of US nursing school graduates and often take the exam multiple times.

While the demand for foreign educated nurses is low at this time, improvements in the national economy and increased demand for nurses resulting from expanded health insurance coverage from the Affordable Care Act may trigger a new cycle of hospital nurse recruitment from abroad.  Thus knowing more about the potential implications of importing foreign educated nurses now is important in nursing workforce planning for the future.

Researchers from the University of Pennsylvania’s (Penn’s) Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research in the School of Nursing in collaboration with the University of Florida’s College of Nursing in Gainesville undertook a study to determine whether U.S. hospital employment of non-US-educated nurses is associated with higher mortality after common surgical procedures, and if so, under what circumstances. They found that in hospitals in which patient-to-nurse ratios were average (five patients per nurse) or worse, mortality and failure to rescue patients with complications is significantly higher when 25 percent or more nurses were educated outside the U.S.

The study, “Utilization of non-US educated nurses in US hospitals: implications for hospital mortality,” was published in June 2013 in the International Journal for Quality in Health Care. The study was funded by the National Institute of Nursing and RWJF.

This study of 665 hospitals directed by Penn’s Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research is one of the largest ever undertaken of the potential quality of care impact of utilization of non-US educated nurses in US hospitals.  The senior author of the paper is University of Pennsylvania professor and director of the School of Nursing’s Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research and Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics senior fellow, Linda H Aiken, RN, PhD, FAAN.  Co-authors include Donna Neff, RN, PhD, Associate Professor, University of Florida College of Nursing, Jeannie Cimiotti, RN, PhD, FAAN, formerly from Penn and now Associate Professor at Rutgers University College of Nursing and Director of the New Jersey Collaborating Center for Nursing, and Douglas M. Sloane, PhD, Adjunct Professor of Nursing at Penn.

The study concludes that employing substantial numbers of non-US-educated nurses in U.S. hospitals is associated with significantly higher risk-adjusted 30 day from admission mortality and failure to rescue patients who experience complications after common general, orthopedic, and vascular surgery. Only when nurse staffing in hospitals is better than average, as when nurses care for four or fewer patients each, do we find no effect of foreign educated nurses on mortality. Only 37 percent of hospitals in the study had staffing ratios of four patients per nurse or less.  The effect of having more than 25 percent non-US-educated nurses becomes increasingly deleterious as patient-to-nurse ratios increased beyond 5:1. Thus, in practical terms, high proportions of non-US-educated nurses are a potential risk factor for excess mortality.

Recruiting nurses from countries with greater burdens of illness and fewer nurses than the U.S. has been criticized in terms of its potential adverse effect on global health.  This study suggests that it is not in the public’s interest in the U.S. to rely extensively on foreign educated nurses.

The findings suggest that the US should be largely reliant on its own domestic supply of nurses to prevent future nursing shortages which would require better national nurse workforce planning and policy intervention to balance domestic nurse supply and likely future demands for nurses.         

Monday, September 9, 2013

Research Brief: Impact of Nurse Characteristics and Practices on Patient Outcomes

An INQRI team led by Nancy Donaldson and Carolyn Aydin examined individual and collective effects of unit level nurse workload, staff nurse characteristics and selected risk assessment and preventive intervention processes of care on variance in nursing sensitive outcomes of acute care medical-surgical units. The team found that patient outcomes were predicted by combinations of all elements in their model, including: unit/patient characteristics, nursing workload, registered nurse expertise and clinical processes. Interestingly, they found that falls and falls with injury were predicted by patient characteristics and clinical process variables, but not by nurse expertise. However, hospital acquired pressure ulcer prevalence was predicted by a combination of all elements in the model. Finally, the team also found that unit and patient characteristics and workload could predict medication practice errors and that workload and practice errors predicted medication outcome errors. These findings can guide hospitals in efforts to improve staffing effectiveness and patient safety, reducing medication administration errors and understanding prevalence of facility acquired pressure ulcers.

Access the research brief.

This post is part of a series to provide the public with research briefs on INQRI-funded projects across a range of interests.

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Staffing, Quality, and Costs

The New York State Nurses Association is supporting a bill currently under discussion in the New York state legislature that would establish required nurse staffing ratios in the state's 185 acute care hospitals.  The hospitals oppose the bill, noting that the suggested ratios would cost their institutions and nursing homes about $3 billion a year and would affect their ability to shift staff use as needed.

This is an important conversation, given that research is demonstrating that nurse staffing levels have a definite impact on the quality of patient care.

INQRI researchers Mary Blegen and Tom Vaughn examined the extent to which nurse staffing levels affected the incidence of complications and the failure to rescue from those complications, (i.e. death following complications). Their examination showed that nursing hours per patient day were strongly associated with lower rates of pressure ulcers and hospital acquired infections, and fewer deaths from complications. Further, more RN hours in the mix had additional benefit with still lower rates of failure to rescue and hospital acquired infections. Their work shows that higher levels of nursing hours per patient day and RN skill mix in intensive care units and in general units will lead to better patient outcomes, information that can guide states considering regulation of nurse-patient staffing ratios to address patient safety gaps.

Findings from the first study to look at the link between nursing and very low birthweight infants in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) indicate that nurse staffing and practice environment do matter. INQRI researchers Eileen Lake and Jeannette Rogowski examined care in more than 100 NICUs around the U.S. and found that when babies are treated in units where nurses have less support and less frontline experience they are at higher risk of developing infections. Babies in hospitals where nurses are supported and have more experience are less likely to have medical complications such as bleeding in the brain, which leads to costly complications. The study results could guide decisions related to setting standards for all hospitals to follow when creating and staffing a neonatal intensive care unit where infants thrive.

Click here to read an article about the New York legislation in the Wall Street Journal.
Click here to learn more about the Blegen-Vaughn study.
Click here to learn more about the Lake-Rogowski study.